Wednesday, June 19, 2024

Effects of In-Person and Online Chronic Disease Self-Management Education (CDSME) Programs on Reducing Loneliness: A Research Proposal and Overview

Effects of In-Person and Online Chronic Disease Self-Management Education (CDSME) Programs on Reducing Loneliness: A Research Proposal and Overview


Alexander Fitzgerald




Introduction


Problem and Impacts

Loneliness refers to a discouraging emotion arising from lacking meaningful social relationships and it is a public health problem that interferes with quality of life among adults with chronic disease. Chronic disease is accompanied by a series of physical and mental health issues which may make it more difficult to interact with others and maintain social relationships (Christiansen et al., 2020; Smith et al., 2022). The burden of disease may also increase difficulty with tasks of daily living, decreasing available time to foster social interaction. This leads to social isolation which may exacerbate existing or cause new physical and mental health problems (Christiansen et al., 2020; Douma et al., 2021). According to social cognitive theory, feelings of social isolation are one of the most significant risk factors that influence behavior which, in turn, diminishes the ability to maintain healthy behaviors within the environmental context. Loneliness can also lead to other consequences for people with chronic diseases such as higher cost of care, diminished sense of identity and purpose, low self-efficacy, and inability to manage one’s own health (Chen et al., 2018; Lenferink et al., 2018). 

Currently, around 51.8% of adults in the U.S.A have a diagnosis of at least one chronic disease with 27% having two or more comorbid chronic conditions (Boersma et al., 2020). Medical costs for chronic disease may vary by disease but the overall cost exceeds $1 trillion per year (Hacker, 2024). Additionally, the elderly population is projected to reach nearly double the current population by 2050. As elderly people face the highest burden of chronic disease, the increasing elderly population means significant increases in the medical costs for chronic disease care (Maresova et al., 2019).

Due to the consequences of loneliness on health outcomes in adults with chronic diseases, as well as the prevalence and cost of chronic disease today, it is important to advance research regarding understanding how interventions for adults with chronic disease can address loneliness as a route for maximizing ability to self-manage individual health needs.


Importance to Social Work

The proposed research study is important to the field of social work by upholding ethical values in line with the NASW Code of Ethics (2021) and advancing the mission of social workers. In exploring the connection between loneliness and chronic disease, the study directly promotes the importance of human relationships and recognizes them as a pathway for change. The results will inform future practice around addressing loneliness and social support allowing for more effective support provided to clients dealing with these issues. Competence is also promoted by expanding knowledge in this area of practice for more application in the field. Knowledge on chronic disease and how to improve social support and health management in this population will put social workers in a position to increase quality of life for clients. Better health outcomes will allow social worker and client teams to focus on other issues requiring support. Finally, this study promotes social justice and equity by developing interventions for improved quality of life for the vulnerable population of adults with chronic diseases. Analyzing virtual and in-person interventions may also highlight methods of minimizing costs, time commitments, and mobility issues in administering such treatments. This information on delivery method effectiveness will help social workers make educated decisions about the best method of intervention administration for a client’s specific needs and obstacles, expanding accessibility of support. 


Literature Review

Prior to the development of the research question, a thorough literature review was conducted to inform the direction of this study. Several studies were found to be relevant. 

A study conducted by Smith et al. (2022) examines the effectiveness of Chronic Disease Self-Management Education (CDMSE) programs on reducing loneliness in people with chronic disease. Researcher’s hypothesized that if a person who participated in in-person CDSME workshops will have lower levels of loneliness. The study employed a Classic Pre-test Post-test design and the sample consisted of adults over age 50 with a chronic disease. They used a convenience sample recruited at multiple sites like libraries and senior centers. The findings demonstrated significant improvement in loneliness scale scores from baseline to six weeks. In an adjusted model, improvement was found to be more significant for participants who were younger, Asian, and/or had a higher number of chronic diseases. 

This study also had some limitations. Firstly, the study relied on self-report data which could be impacted by recall or social desirability bias. Secondly, the study was conducted over six weeks with no comparison group used which limits the external validity of the results. Recommendations for future research are to examine the effects on loneliness of virtual CDSME programs as well as incorporating comparison groups into future studies. (Smith, 2022)

A second study investigated the potential benefits of group identification with a chronic disease self-management group on improving self-efficacy, and correspondingly, self-management skills. Researcher’s hypothesized that if a person identifies strongly with the group, then they will have better self-efficacy and self-management ability. A Single Group Pre-Test Post-Test design was used with secondary data from a previous study. The sample consisted of 213 adults aged 44-88 with a diagnosis of a chronic condition. The results suggest that social identification in a group-based self-management program predicts improvement of self-efficacy, and thus, self-management skills. Improved self-efficacy predicted better mental and physical health state at a four month follow-up (Cameron et al. 2018).

Some limitations in this study included a sample size below the optimal limit for evaluation as well as an inability to determine causality due to the correlational nature of the data used. Researchers recommend future studies explore benefits beyond four months and interventions should promote self-identification and group membership for positive health outcomes (Cameron et al, 2018). 

In 2021, Douma et al. conducted a study to evaluate the effectiveness of Op Koers Online group interventions on improving health coping strategies in adolescents with chronic disease. The hypothesis stated if adolescents participate in Op Koers Online program then they will demonstrate increased self-management abilities. Using a classic pre-test post-test design, an availability sample was gathered from local hospitals consisting of adolescents ages 12-18 who had a current chronic disease diagnosis. 89% of subjects completed a majority of the sessions and findings demonstrated improvement in health-related coping skills for the treatment group while no improvement was seen in the control group. 

This study had a few limitations including a lower response rate leading to a sample size below the desired number of participants. Response rate could also not be calculated due to the online recruitment. The results may be beneficial in Outcomes were also self-reported and have risk of recall or social desirability bias. For the future, researchers advise programs to increase parental involvement and work to maintain benefits at one-year follow-up. Research studies should further evaluate the connection between quality of life and disease-related coping skills (Douma et al., 2021).

Another study, carried out by Christiansen et al., (2020),  aimed to investigate the association between social isolation (SI) and loneliness as predictors of chronic disease. Researchers hypothesized that if social isolation and loneliness interact, then an individual is at higher risk for developing chronic disease. Using a cross-sectional cohort study, secondary data from a 2013 study with a sample of adults aged 35-79, was analyzed. The results of this study suggest that the interaction between SI and loneliness increases the risk of developing chronic disease, more than the presence of either SI or loneliness alone. Findings indicated that both psychological and behavioral pathways can partially explain the association of SI and loneliness with chronic disease. 

This study faced several limitations. Firstly, causality could not be established. Additionally, the presence of a confounding variable could not be ruled out. Finally, care should be taken with analyzing data as the mediation model used for analysis was not a perfect fit. Future research should be conducted on the relationship of loneliness and SI with specific chronic diseases as well as aim to establish a causal relationship (Christiansen et al., 2020). 

Finally, Chen et al. (2018) designed a study to explore the relationship between social support and health literacy on self-management skills in people with Chronic Kidney Disease (CKD). They hypothesize that if a person has higher levels of social support and health literacy then they will have better self-management skills. Quota sampling was applied to secondary data to control the proportion of participants at each disease stage. The final sample included 410 patients. The results suggest that both social support and health literacy are predictors of self-management skills, but social support is the strongest indicator of better self-management skills, health outcomes, and quality of life. Social support from healthcare providers and family were found to be significant.

The first limitation of this study is that participants tended to be older, less-educated, and dealing with later-stage CKD which may decrease generalizability. Another limitation is that self-report information may have recall or social desirability bias. Finally, no causal relationship could be established. In future research, a system-approach should be used to evaluate the social support pathway as well as identify other explanatory factors. Additionally, research should examine the link between health literacy and possible mediating variables for self-management (Chen et al, 2018). 

Previous studies have provided a lot of direction for future research that has inspired this study. Research has shown self-efficacy to be a mediating variable between health and social support, but more research is needed in this area. By studying loneliness and self-efficacy as predictor variables of self-management skills, this study will help further explain this relationship. Furthermore, past studies have demonstrated that in-person workshops may improve loneliness, but this was not examined virtually (Cameron et al., 2018; Smith et al., 2022). A separate study found positive effects on loneliness and self-management for chronic disease via online intervention, but with an adolescent population (Douma et al, 2021). This study aims to fill this gap in the research by exploring the complex relationship between self-management, loneliness, and self-efficacy in adults with chronic disease by comparing in-person and virtual interventions in the same study. 


Hypothesis

The finalized study will aim to examine the effectiveness of in-person as opposed to virtual self-management interventions in impacting loneliness and self-efficacy. The researcher hypothesizes that if participants are in the in-person intervention then they will score lower loneliness and higher self-efficacy levels than participants in the virtual intervention. 


Theoretical Background 

This research idea and hypothesis have also been informed by social cognitive theory. Social cognitive theory states that personal and environmental factors can interact to shape behaviors, as well as the idea that behavior is partially learned through observation and social interaction. Further, the theory looks at self-efficacy as an important factor for behavior changes (Sell et al., 2016). Loneliness or lack of social interaction are factors which could impact behavior change. Increased loneliness can hinder behavior changes by diminishing an individual’s sense of self-efficacy. Self-efficacy is essential to proper self-management of chronic disease. As a lot of adults with chronic disease struggle with loneliness, this could impact their self-efficacy and self-management skills. This study explores reducing loneliness in adults with chronic disease as a route to behavior change for improved health management. The in-person intervention has already been shown to reduce loneliness. The researcher hypothesis suggests that the in-person sessions will produce more group interaction and social engagement to encourage meaningful relationships. Higher volume of significant social interactions will be more effective at reducing loneliness, and, following social cognitive theory, then lead to more significant increases in self-efficacy and self-management skills.


METHODOLOGY


Research Design

The experiment will follow a Classic Experimental Pre-test Post-test research design.

This design involves two groups, a treatment group and a control group. The first step is to randomly assign the participants to either the control or treatment group. Before the treatment is administered both the DV for both groups will be measured, allowing for additional measurements to be collected. The two groups will then undergo their intervention before having the DV measured again. This design allows comparison of DV before and after experiencing a treatment and also allows a causal relationship to be determined.  

Researchers chose this design for the study for several reasons. Firstly, this design was selected in order to have a comparison group to improve internal validity. Additionally, this design involves random assignment which is important to eliminate selection bias and ensure higher internal validity. A design involving both a pre-test and post-test measure was also used because it can better establish and measure a causal relationship (Engel & Schutt, 2017).


Sampling Method

For this study, researchers will use snowball sampling. Snowball sampling begins with identifying a few individuals in the population to participate. These individuals will be given the information about the study and asked to share this study with other individuals they know who may meet the study criteria. The sample is built from participant connections (Engel & Schutt, 2017). The criteria will require participants to be adults aged fifty and older with at least one chronic disease. Chronic disease will be operationalized as a disease lasting one year or more involving physical or mental symptoms that interfere with regular daily living activities. Participants must be able to access both the in-person and virtual settings to be considered. 

The initial participants for this study will be recruited via medical facilities. As individuals with chronic disease require regular follow-up, local primary care physicians will be informed about this study and its requirements and asked to encourage eligible patients to participate. Additional participants will be recruited by the initial participants. 

There is no sampling frame for individuals with chronic disease which makes it very difficult to obtain a randomized sample from this population. Because this would be nearly impossible, an availability method was preferred. Snowball sampling was the preferred method of availability sampling because it will allow quicker recruitment of participants and also help to recruit participants who do not need to see their physician as regularly.

Advantages of using this method are that it is quicker and more flexible, allows collection of a sample without an available sampling frame, and low-cost. A major disadvantage of this method is that the sample will not be representative of the population so there is very low ability to generalize. Additionally, there can be issues with data analysis because many statistical tests assume a random sample so the results may be inaccurate (Engel & Schutt, 2017).




Measurement Strategies

The independent variable is the treatment type which may be online or in-person. The dependent variables will be level of loneliness and level of self-efficacy. The independent variable is a nominal variable and both dependent variables are measured on a ratio level.

Loneliness will be assessed using the Three-Item Loneliness Scale. Participants can answer on a three point scoring scale with 1 meaning hardly ever and 3 meaning often. Higher scores indicate a higher level of loneliness. The Three-Item Loneliness Scale was chosen because it has high alternate forms reliability with a correlation of 0.82. This scale also had good convergent validity with other scales for assessing loneliness. Additionally, this scale only had three questions to avoid participants tiring out during the survey (Hughes et al., 2004). 

For self-efficacy the scale used would be the Self-Efficacy for Disease Management Measure. This scale is a three-item scale and scored from 1-10 with 1 being not at all confident and 10 being very confident. Similarly, the Self-Efficacy for Disease Management Measure also had high reliability with a Cronbach’s alpha of 0.91. This measure was designed specifically for use with CDSME programs making this scale the most appropriate to use for this study design. Finally, this survey also only has three items ensuring participants do not tire out and can answer all questions.  (Melchior et al., 2014). 

Both loneliness and self-efficacy will be assessed at baseline, immediately after the intervention, and at the six week point. The surveys will be administered virtually for the virtual intervention group and by paper for the in-person intervention group.  


Data Analysis

Both descriptive and inferential statistics will be used to analyze the data and explain the results. Demographic data, such as race or gender, will be described using frequencies. The nominal nature of these variables makes a frequency table the most effective method to display this data. The independent variable is also nominal with only two categories, so frequency can also be used to indicate the distribution of participants across these categories. Both dependent variables are measured as ratio level data making measures of central tendency more appropriate descriptors. Specifically, median and range will be used to share results on loneliness and self-efficacy in order to avoid any inaccuracies that may come from skewness if mean was used. 

For inferential statistics, comparative statistics are the most appropriate because this design involves contrasting two different treatment groups by method of intervention delivery. Because this study has identified a categorical independent variable and two continuous dependent variables, MANOVA is the most appropriate method of analysis as it is the only one meant for multiple dependent variables (Engel & Schutt, 2017). 


Ethical Considerations

There are many ethical considerations to consider in regards to this research study. First, it is essential that participants provide voluntary, informed consent before any involvement in the study. Packets detailing the purpose of the study, the methodology, risks, and other relevant information will be provided to each participant. Participants will also be provided researcher contact information in case there are any questions. Each participant must return a signed form acknowledging they have read and understand the informed consent document. 

A second significant consideration is privacy. Because one group is in-person and one is virtual, there are unique challenges for maintaining anonymity. Virtual groups will be required to have their cameras turned on in order to maintain equal anonymity between groups. Snowball sampling makes it likely that participants will know others in their treatment group but to preserve more anonymity only first names will be used in sessions. No names or identifying information will be published. Participants' names will be removed from their data and coded as a number only in order to preserve confidentiality. As this data is not particularly sensitive, Certificates of Confidentiality will not be used. 

Because this is human subjects research, this study also requires review by the IRB for additional assessment of ethical needs. This study would be classified as expedited because it is not anonymous but involves minimal risk to the participants (Engel & Schutt, 2017). At this time the researcher has no conflicts of interest which may impact the study. 


Study Limitations

There are a few limitations with this study’s methodology that are important to be aware of. Firstly, the use of snowball sampling worked best for this population, but it will likely only yield a small sample. This means the study will be heavily impacted by any participant attrition or incompletion of the program and surveys. Secondly, the study results will have low external validity because snowball sampling does not produce a random sample. The sample will not be generalizable because it is not representative of the population. 

Another limitation is the appropriateness of the measures selected. While both measures have high reliability and the Three-Item Loneliness Scale also had good convergent validity, validity was not reported for the Self-Efficacy for Disease Management Measure (Melchior et al., 2014). The lack of assessment of the validity of this measure may lead to inaccuracies in the results. Finally, MANOVA was selected for the comparative analysis in this study because two dependent variables are being examined. While MANOVA is the most appropriate measure for multiple dependent variables, it also requires a categorical independent variable with at least three categories, and the independent variable of this study only has two. This may mean the analysis will not entirely fit the data and produce some inaccuracies in results. 


Monitoring and Implementation Guidelines

To ensure the intervention is carried out and delivered as planned, the inputs were reviewed. Sampling strategy for obtaining participants was already established, but trained program facilitators are also needed to lead the programs. A description of the research project and position and conduct thorough interviews of applicants to determine their fit. To ensure the program leaders are properly trained, the researcher will provide a required training, whether or not they have had previous training. The materials for the CDSME program will be obtained directly from organizations administering the program. Researchers will reach out to the National Council on Aging, Administration for Community Living, and other organizations which run CDSME programs in order to obtain the necessary materials. The experiment will also require both an in-person and virtual space to conduct sessions. The in-person space will be a room rented from an accessible local library or community center nearby the original recruitment site. The virtual sessions will be run from a computer within the designated research lab space or office in order to protect privacy and ensure reliable internet access. A recurring zoom link will be emailed to participants to access the session. Taking these steps will ensure the intervention delivered is high-quality and delivered effectively to participants. 

In implementing the intervention, the first aspect to monitor ensuring participants are aware of all the details regarding location and timing. The in-person location and virtual link will be shared with the relevant participants two weeks prior to the first session. A reminder will be sent three days prior. For every session including the first, a reminder with the information will be sent out the morning of the session. An RSVP form will be included in the two week and three day notice emails to help verify participants have received and seen the information. Regarding the virtual sessions, to avoid technical difficulties eating into session time, researchers will test both the instructor and participant side of the zoom link to confirm it is functional. Instructors will be provided with lesson plans and training well in advance, but to ensure the lesson plans are followed researchers will supervise sessions. For the virtual sessions, the researcher will be in the room with the instructor to listen to the session, but out of view of the participants in order not to interfere with the experiment. For the in-person session, the researcher will set up and watch a live stream of the classroom. This will only be viewed by the researcher for monitoring and will not be saved or recorded after the session to ensure confidentiality. 

Additional outcomes such as increased level of social support, and increased knowledge and ability to self manage and engage in positive health behaviors will be evaluated. A survey asking about perceived social support, self-management skills, and health behaviors will be administered at the same points the DV measures will be administered, pre-intervention, immediately post-intervention, and six weeks after, for outcome evaluation. 

Finally, in order to assess the effectiveness of this intervention, a cost benefit analysis can be run after completion comparing the costs of conducting the intervention to the costs of hospitalization and healthcare that would be needed if participants did not receive the intervention.


Application of Evaluation Research

Cost benefit analysis will demonstrate whether this intervention successfully addresses the problem in a cost-effective way (Engel & Schutt, 2017) . The implications of these findings are primarily applicable to macro society. If the program saves on costs, the amount of healthcare spending required by the government would decrease allowing extra money to be used for other programs like SNAP. This would improve practice effectiveness by allowing more individuals in need of these programs to access them, increasing delivery speed and efficacy, and prioritizing the most-needed programs.

From the opposite side, if the program loses money it would not be worth it for the government to implement as it would be a waste of money and resources. This would mean no additional resources would be freed up preventing any improvement in services or delivery. While it would not negatively impact practice because the government budget would not decrease, it would also mean there would be no increase in practice efficiency. 

Overall, the proposed research will impact multiple systems levels by advancing understanding of the relationship between loneliness and chronic disease, the benefits of virtual compared to in-person interventions for loneliness, and informing future research and practice for adults with chronic disease and beyond. 


References

Boersma, P., Black, L. I., & Ward, B. W. (2020). Prevalence of multiple chronic conditions among US adults, 2018. Preventing Chronic Disease, 17. http://dx.doi.org/10.5888/pcd17.200130

Cameron, J., Voth, J., Jaglal, S., Guilder, S., Hawker, G., & Salbach, N. (2018). “In this together”: Social identification predicts health outcomes (via self-efficacy) in a chronic disease self-management program. Social Science & Medicine, 208, 172-179. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2018.03.007

Chen, Y., Chang, L., Liu, C., Ho, Y., Weng. S., & Tsai, T. (2018) The roles of social support and health literacy in self-management among patients with chronic kidney disease. Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 50(3), 265-275. https://doi.org/10.1111/jnu.12377

Christiansen, J., Lund, R., Qualter, P., Andersen, C., Pedersen, S., & Lasgaard, M. (2020). Loneliness, social isolation, and chronic disease outcomes. Annals of Behavioral Medicine, 55(3),  203-215. https://doi.org/10.1093/abm/kaaa044

Douma, M., Maurice-Stam, H., Gorter, B., Houtzager, B., Vreugdenhil, H., Waaldjik, M., Wiltink, L., Grootenhuis, M., & Scholten, L. (2021). Online psychosocial group intervention for adolescents with a chronic illness: A randomized controlled trial. Internet Interventions, 26. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.invent.2021.100447

Engel, R. J. & Schutt, R. K. (2017). The Practice of Research in Social Work. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications

Hacker, K. (2024).  The burden of chronic disease. Lifestyle Medicine, 8(1), 112-119. 10.1016/j.mayocpiqo.2023.08.005

Hughes, M. E., Waite, L. J., Hawkley, L. C., & Cacioppo, J. T. (2004). Three-Item Loneliness Scale. PsycTESTS. https://doi-org.proxy-bc.researchport.umd.edu/10.1037/t29584-000

Lenferink, A., Van der Palen, J., & Effing, T. (2018) The role of social support in improving chronic obstructive pulmonary disease self-management. Expert Review of Respiratory Medicine, 12(8), 623-626. https://doi.org/10.1080/17476348.2018.1489723

Maresova, P., Javanmardi, E., Barakovic, S., Husic, J. B., Tomsone, S., Krejcar, O., & Kuca, K. (2019). Consequences of chronic diseases and other limitations associated with old age - A scoping review. BMC Public Health, 19. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-019-7762-5

Melchior, M. A., Seff, L. R., Albatineh, A. N., McCoy, H. V., & Page, T. F. (2014). Self-Efficacy for Disease Management Measure. PsycTESTS. https://doi-org.proxy-bc.researchport.umd.edu/10.1037/t33758-000

National Association of Social Workers. (2021). NASW Code of Ethics. https://www.socialworkers.org/About/Ethics/Code-of-Ethics/Code-of-Ethics-English

Sell, K., Amella, E., Mueller, M., Andrews, J., & Wachs, J. (2016). Use of Social Cognitive Theory to assess salient clinical research in chronic disease self-management for older adults: An integrative review. Open Journal of Nursing, 6(3), 213-228. DOI: 10.4236/ojn.2016.63022

Smith, M., Chen, E., Lau, C., Davis, D., Simmons, J., & Merianos, A. (2022). Effectiveness of chronic disease self-management education (CDSME) programs to reduce loneliness.  Chronic Illness, 19(3), 646-664. https://doi.org/10.1177/17423953221113604

Wednesday, December 27, 2023

The Rights of Children with Disabilities to A Free, Appropriate Public Education


The Rights of Children with Disabilities to a Free, Appropriate Public Education

Alex Fitzgerald



Education is a vital aspect of social justice. Educating children with disabilities in mainstream settings provides equal opportunities for people with disabilities to be educated to the same extent as their non-disabled peers (Hehir 2016, p.4). Education became a legal right for all disabled children in the United States with the passage of The Education for All Handicapped Children Act of 1975 (EHA), later renamed the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) (Spaulding & Pratt, 2015, p. 91). This federal law mandates all state and local public-school districts to provide a “free, appropriate education” (FAPE) to all children and youth with disabilities (Lipkin & Okamoto, 2015, p.2).

The practice of educating students with disabilities in a mainstream environment, known as “inclusion,” is an important social concept that improves the lives of disabled children and has a positive impact on non-disabled students as well (Hehir 2016, p.7). Prior to 1975, at least one million disabled children in the United States were denied access to the public school system: many living in institutions with little or no education. (Aron & Loprest, p.100). 

Approximately 15% of children nationwide have a disability (Lipkin & Okamoto, 2015, p.1), with the prevalence of those children living in poverty and being children of color (Young & Crankshaw, 2021). The number of children with disabilities has increased over the past decade, but it is not clear if that is a true increase or a change in how disabilities are diagnosed (Young & Crankshaw, 2021).

Inclusion is an important concept in policy practice that involves addressing segregation from regular classrooms and unfair treatment among these groups that existed before (Aron & Loprest 2012, p.99). In addition, non-disabled students also benefit from inclusion by developing meaningful relationships with disabled peers without holding prejudices, stereotypes against them, or fears about human differences (Hehir et al., 2016). In fact, evidence suggests that including children and youth with disabilities in mainstream educational systems alongside non-disabled classmates is linked to higher rates of enrollment in schools and improved teaching practices in which all students benefit from the same levels of academic achievement. This educational benefit of inclusion was demonstrated in a study commissioned by the Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education in 2011 that followed three Boston schools for two years (Hehir et al., 2012). The study found that inclusion led to more innovating teaching practices and higher achievement for all students (Hehir et al., 2016, p.11). 

In 1975 President Gerald Ford signed into law the Education for All Handicapped Children Act (EHA) which required states to provide equal access to education for all students with disabilities (Jansson, 2019, p.621). Also known as Public Law 94-142, the EHA has been reauthorized and expanded over the years to become the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), granting funding for states to administer early intervention for children ages 3-5 and special education programs for school-aged children in the basis of disability (Murphy, 1996, p.2). The IDEA guarantees children with disabilities the right to attend public school alongside their non-disabled peers and receive the services they need to help reach their goals at no cost (Aron & Loprest, 2012, p.99).   

According to the IDEA, every child with a disability must be identified and evaluated through a process called “child find.” The law also prohibits exclusion from public education, implements the Individualized Education Program, and allows parents of children with disabilities to collaborate with the school to ensure academic goals are met (Yell et al., 2020, p. 307). All school districts must ensure equal access to educational resources so that a disabled student is fully integrated into classrooms with the right to seek reasonable accommodations (Yell et al., 2020). Despite a substantial increase in children with disabilities enrolled in inclusive education since the passage of IDEA, many still face challenges in accessing educational standards in other countries where these policies on inclusion are not yet in effect (Hehir et al., 2016, p.6). 

Educating children with disabilities in the least restrictive environment is an important social justice issue which is good for society. Inclusive education promotes social equality and instills the idea that every member of society is valued and important (Hehir et al., 2016). Until 1975, most children with disabilities in the United States were marginalized and segregated from mainstream education (Spaulding & Pratt, 2015, p.97). Significant progress in legislative action on policy practice of education was made with the passage of IDEA, which creates a positive impact on resource development for school systems to offer an inclusive curriculum. The policy highlights regulations and procedures that require state and local districts to implement an Individualized Education Plan and make sure that all qualified students with disabilities have equal access to reasonable accommodations (Lipkin & Okamoto, 2015, p. 2).

Despite significant progress, more work needs to be done. Even with IDEA, students with disabilities are often behind educationally compared to their peers and are at risk of dropping out of school (Aron & Loprest, 2012, p. 114). Another limitation of IDEA is higher education. Although the IDEA works to prepare students with disabilities for future educational opportunities and employment, IDEA does not continue once a student graduates from high school (Lipkin & Okamoto, 2015, p. 11). Therefore, more focus should be placed on to accommodating disabled students transitioning from high school to the university level (Madaus 2011).


References


Aron, L., & Loprest, P. (2012). Disability and the education system. The Future of children, 22(1), 97–122. 


Hehir, T., Grindal, T., Freeman, B., Lamoreau, R., Borquaye, Y., & Burke, S. (2016). A Summary of the Evidence on Inclusive Education. In Abt Associates. Abt Associates.


Hehir, T., Grindal, T., & Eidelman, H. (2012). Review of special education in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. Boston, MA: Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education. https://www.bostonpublicschools.org/cms/lib/MA01906464/Centricity/Domain/249/Hehir%20SynthesisReport.pdf


Jansson, B. S. (2019). The reluctant welfare state (9th ed.). Cengage.

Lipkin, P. H., Okamoto, J., Council on Children with Disabilities, & Council on School Health (2015). The Individuals With Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) for Children With Special Educational Needs. Pediatrics, 136(6), e1650–e1662. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2015-3409


Madaus, J. W. (2011). The History of Disability Services in higher education. New Directions for Higher Education, 2011(154), 5–15. https://doi-org.proxy-bc.researchport.umd.edu/10.1002/he.429


Murphy, D. M. (1996). Implications of Inclusion for General and Special Education. The Elementary School Journal, 96(5), 469–493. http://www.jstor.org/stable/1001845


Spaulding, L. S., & Pratt, S. M. (2015). Article 7: A review and analysis of the history of special education and disability advocacy in the United States. American Educational History Journal, 42(1-2), 91+. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A437059641/AONE?u=anon~f3e148c0&sid=googleScholar&xid=7eaef694


Yell, M. L., Collins, J., Kumpiene, G., & Bateman, D. (2020). The Individualized Education Program: Procedural and Substantive Requirements. Teaching Exceptional Children, 52(5), 304–318. https://doi-org.proxy-bc.researchport.umd.edu/10.1177/0040059920906592

Young, N. & Crankshaw, K. (2021, October 8). Disability rates highest among American Indian and Alaska native children and children living in poverty. Census.gov. Retrieved February 25, 2023, from https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2021/03/united-states-childhood-disability-rate-up-in-2019-from-2008.html 

The History of Disability and Education in the U.S.


The History of Disability and Education in the United States

Alex Fitzgerald


Introduction

The reform on education for children with disabilities was established during the 1800s and historically influenced the structure of social policy and institutions regarding integrating disabled children into public schools. This paper covers the history of disability education rights movements from the early 1800’s to present. 

History of the Social Issue

  The definition of “disability” has changed over time and shapes how scholars think and analyze the approach to inclusion and exclusion in the contemporary era (Altschuler & Silva, 2017). The medical model and the social model (nature vs. nurture) are the two main perspectives that are explored in historical literature. The medical model defines disability as an abnormality in a person’s physical or mental conditions that reduces quality of life and views disability as a biological impairment in terms of health and functioning that should be cured (Kudlick, 2005). The social model emerged in the United States during the 1960’s and was concerned with equality of opportunity to participate in society. (Cigman, 2010). The social model focuses on consequences of social and environmental barriers that exclude an individual from participating in society. 

The first era of educational reform began during the Civil War and abolitionist movement, which prompted states and the federal government to create public institutions for the deaf, blind, and mentally challenged (Madaus). The development of special education programs began with Beverly schools in the early 1800’s, and in 1823 the first school for the deaf was built in Kentucky (Guidara, 2013). In 1864 Gallaudet became the first college for the deaf when President Lincoln signed a bill into law that created more schools for the deaf at a federal level (Madaus, 2011). However, it wasn’t until 1913 that disabled children started receiving individual attention through special education (Guidara, 2013). Changes to policies and institutions of higher education after World War I and World War II resulted in an influx of veterans with disabilities attending college. The Soldier’s Rehabilitation Act of 1918 and the G.I Bill of Rights Act of 1944 provided aid to veterans with disabilities with equal access to educational experiences and job training upon graduation.  It restored in an increase of individuals with disabilities entering public schools throughout the 21st century (Monyl).

 In the 1959’s an opportunity to seek civil rights laws and education legislation became widely accepted that shaped societal and political attitudes toward disability, The contemporary era of special education (1950-present) was a shift from segregation (medical model) to inclusion (social model) (Cigman, 2010). During the 1950’s, advocacy groups fought against segregation in public schools. In 1953, Brown vs. Board of Education declared segregation as unconstitutional, and in 1972, Mills v. Board of Education of District of Columbia established that all children are entitled to a “free appropriate public education”. These cases helped to establish the foundation for the 1975 law, Education for All Handicapped Children Act or EAHCA (Spaulding & Pratt, 2015). The EAHCA required states to provide equal access to education for all students with disabilities (Jansson, 2019). This law was expanded over the years to become the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), granting funding for states to administer early intervention and special education programs for school-aged children with disabilities (Murphy, 1996). The most recent law, Every Student Succeeds Act of 2015, reauthorized the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, and improved provisions under IDEA. These pieces of legislation expanded equal opportunities for all students, leading to higher rates of high school graduation and enrollment in post-secondary education (Madaus, 2011). 

Oppression/Discrimination

Cultural attitudes, absence of polices and lack of access to education are the primary ways in which people with disabilities have been oppressed throughout history (Spaulding & Pratt, 2015). Contributing factors of disability discrimination included race, gender, poverty, neglect, superstition, and ignorance of disability (Munyi, 2012). 

Early American disability studies suggest that the meaning of disability was originally viewed as an application of identity based on physical and cognitive differences, leading to stigma and disgrace (Altscher). The disabled often experienced exploitation, expulsion from society, and even execution. People with disabilities were often put in almshouses and prisons as a measure that segregated them from society. As a result, many children with disabilities were institutionalized or hidden from society and received no education (Spaulding & Pratt, 2015). 

An absence of laws protecting the disabled and the physical inaccessibility also contributed to the lack of educational opportunities for handicapped children. In early history there were no elevators, ramps, or lifts installed in buildings and there was a limited access to public transportation. Before many civil rights laws were passed, school districts had a choice on whether to exclude or include children with disabilities in mainstream or special education programs (Pugach, 2011). The veterans who returned from the war with physical and other types of disabilities also helped to raise public awareness and acceptance and the opportunity to seek legislation and federal laws mandating access to education (Spaulding & Pratt, 2015).

Conclusion

A review and analysis on the history of disability education is concerned with multiple themes highlighting a shift in perspectives from nature to nurture, changes to societal conceptions of individuals with disabilities, and the evolution of special education and inclusion (Spaulding & Pratt, 2015). The contemporary era introduced the normalization and deinstitutionalization movements combating oppression and changing public perceptions of disabilities. Additionally, inclusive education advocates successfully fought for inclusion that ultimately ensured individuals of all ability levels the right to a free and public education and the opportunity to reach their fullest potential.

References

Altschuler, S., & Silva, C. (2017). Early American Disability Studies. Early American Literature, 52(1), 1–27. https://www.jstor.org/stable/90009790

Cigman, R. (2010). Social Model of disability. Social Model of Disability - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics. Retrieved April 2, 2023, from https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/medicine-and-dentistry/social-model-of-disability. 

Guidara, A. (2013, August 8). The history of special education in the late 1800s to mid-1900s: A look through Beverly Schools. Primary Research. Retrieved April 1, 2023, from https://primaryresearch.org/the-history-of-special-education-in-the-late-1800s-to-mid-1900s-a-look-through-beverly-schools/ 

Jansson, B. S. (2019). The reluctant welfare state (9th ed.). Cengage.

Kudlick, C. J. (2005). Disability History, Power, and Rethinking the Idea of “The Other.” PMLA, 120(2), 557–561. http://www.jstor.org/stable/25486184

Madaus, J. W. (2011). The History of Disability Services in higher education. New Directions for Higher Education, 2011(154), 5–15. https://doi-org.proxy-bc.researchport.umd.edu/10.1002/he.429

Munyi, C. W. (2012). Past and present perceptions towards disability: A historical perspective: Disability studies quarterly. Past and Present Perceptions Towards Disability: A Historical Perspective. Retrieved March 29, 2023, from https://dsq-sds.org/index.php/dsq/article/view/3197/3068 

Pugach, M. C., Blanton, L. P., & Correa, V. I. (2011). A Historical Perspective on the Role of Collaboration in Teacher Education Reform: Making Good on the Promise of Teaching All Students. Teacher Education and Special Education, 34(3), 183–200. https://doi.org/10.1177/0888406411406141

Spaulding, L. S., & Pratt, S. M. (2015). Article 7: A review and analysis of the history of special education and disability advocacy in the United States. American Educational History Journal, 42(1-2), 91+. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A437059641/AONE?u=anon~f3e148c0&sid=googleScholar&xid=7eaef694

U.S. Department of the Interior. (n.d.). Disability history: The disability rights movement (U.S. National Park Service). National Parks Service. Retrieved April 16, 2023, from https://www.nps.gov/articles/disabilityhistoryrightsmovement.htm. 

Friday, July 7, 2023

My Path to Stage Lighting

Now that I have some experience in lighting design, I would like to share what I’ve learned about running lights live. I am starting to explore possible pathways and technologies that I could possess for larger events.

Stage lighting is the practice of creating stunning visual displays and effects to engage audiences and set the mood and tone of a live experience. I spent the last couple of years doing all the programming for a show that took place at the FitzFest music festival on May 20th, 2023. It’s fun and a lot of work. I designed and created a bunch of scenes and chases that are saved and played back.

Setting up stage lighting is not as easy as you may think. When I started setting up lighting fixtures, I first looked over the user manuals and read the instructions carefully before I hung them around the room. I had to make sure I got the correct DMX cables to plug in the fixtures so that the DMX input is working properly. Stage lights can be mounted directly on a DJ truss or simple light stand depending on the amount of space it takes in a specific location. I have a 15-foot-long aluminum truss on the back and two T-Bar stands on the front of stage that fit the number of lights I have in the setup. 

I use a DMX-512 console called the OBay 70 controller which allows me to map the scenes with multiple channels (color, brightness, strobe, sensitivity). It is MIDI-competible and easy to use with my foot piano. This type of equipment has helped me be able to know which scenes to select and what key it is on.  Since I cannot operate the console itself with my weak fingers, I’m lucky enough to do it independently with the MIDI pedals and rely on assistance to turn the power on and off.

"Stage lighting is the practice of creating stunning visual displays and effects to engage audiences and set the mood and tone of a live experience."
Each scene is divided into separate fixture groups that come together at the same time. For instance, I have several par cans, 12 moving head lights (both spot and wash), and the Chaucer DJ Mini Kinta and Swarm 5. Some of them are from ADJ and other companies like SHEHDS and U’King. I also use a fog machine that releases fog into the air to make light beams more visible.

Common effects in Stage lighting include flashing, color changing, and side movements. If they are sound activated they have the capacity to sync the music as long as the audio gets picked up. When they are not synchronized automatically through DMX I am capable of operating the light show manually with MIDI so that they are considered sound-active. 

 Alex demonstrating Apache Rose Peacock Midi Pedals

I attend many professional live concerts and local gigs with lots of lights run by a licensed technician that operates the system from the backstage to provide a wide variety of advanced audio/visual effects. I would be interested in learning more about the role of a licensed lighting technician and how they can be designed/set up for event productions.  When I did the research on concert lighting, I got a long list of top production companies that provide audio and visual equipment for events like this. One of these that inspired me is the All Stage & Sound Company that offers a wide range of services from mobile stages and dance floors. The YouTube videos that show how the job is done were useful to me as well. My favorite was the one featuring Mark Cunniffe who was chosen to light Ed Sheeran’s latest concert tour.  Studying this type of stage lighting inspires me and makes me hopeful there may be similar opportunities available for me someday. For now, I am considered a “hobby technician” because I just do it for enjoyment while listening to music and participating in jam sessions. The next steps I will take on my stage lighting journey are going to be more structured. I’m even hoping to purchase more lighting equipment and continue the programming that will give me more options for a bigger show.



Monday, June 12, 2023

Inspiring Musicians with Disabilities

 

On May 20th, 2023, my band Dukes and I completed our first gig featuring myself, Pat Shepherd, Steve Fitzgerald, and Jenee Muller-Thym. After two years of hard work and collaboration, I am thrilled by the band’s progress in rehearsals that led to a successful live event.

 

Being a musician and a disabled individual means I am someone who has a unique perspective in representing people with disabilities in the music industry. My disabilities have never slowed my ability to to do something creative. After I received a cochlear implant at the age of six, I realized how well it responded to rhythm and volume. 

 

Because my disease challenges me physically too, I had tried all kinds of instruments to determine which ones work best for me. Since my father is a musician in a local band, Capital Groove, his offer to teach me music was a huge influence on my performing arts journey.  Back in 2011, I received a midi-pedal keyboard from him and started playing along with drums and bass as well as existing recordings played by other artists. Having my father’s guidance on how to play the keynotes effectively benefited my ability to keep track on specific directions while practicing on my own. But because a regular keyboard is technically difficult for me to control with my fingers, I continue to play the piano on a midi-pedal pad as a modification despite limited use of my hands. After loosing my hearing and vision as a child, listening to music and learning to play different instruments throughout the course of my lifetime has helped me develop the capabilities to perform artistic schemes. I spent a lot of time learning chord progressions on a keyboard, which has helped me to master the songs I’ve worked on.

 

Midi-pedals, the instrument that I practice frequently, provides a wide range of variants that are based on sound. Each variant has its own group of notes similar to a regular instrument. The midi-pedal machine reproduces the sound of any instrument to create sound tracks. This way I don’t have to exhaust myself by forcing my limbs to do movements that hurt a lot. I sometimes write lyrics that I sing in the background, and also have found the confidence to record vocal tracks and then synchronize the beats with drums and piano using a looper.  

 

Most evenings I go to the music studio on our property to record and mix background songs that combine tracks together with the help of my father. I use a program called Logic Pro for mixing and mastering which is easy and quicker than some other software applications.  I am currently learning music theory in order to enhance a deeper understanding of major and minor scales that contain a number of notes played. 

 

In my opinion, music is fun and a great way for people to express themselves, no matter what their ability level is. My first show with Dukes went well, and I’m even hoping to participate in more gigs in the future.

 

Thursday, January 19, 2023

Proposal to Provide Direct Services for College Students with Disabilities

As I get ready to continue my college education, I realize that there is a severe lack of policies in place to address critical challenges in finding personal supports for students like myself at the university level. Because I am severely limited by my mobility, visual, and physical impairments, I must rely on people to accompany me to school, during class, and back home.  If no one is around to help, I cannot go to school. It’s that simple.  Disabled students like myself face multiple challenges in their educational journey, primarily with equal access. While in public school, we have the IDEA (Individuals with Disabilities Education Act) which is written as Part B of Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. This allowed for people like myself to receive all the supports I needed while in the public school system, so that I could access a Free Appropriate Public Education.  This law made sure that I had everything I needed to access my education, including a Direct Support Person (DSP) / Personal Care Attendant (PCA) to attend classes with me and help me access the school physically.  But once I graduated from high school, this law no longer applied to me.  

 

 

Students with disabilities in recent years are the most likely group to be marginalized and excluded from higher education.  Living with Riboflavin Transporter Deficiency (RTD) has forced me and my family to fight for many things educationally, most recently, in the form of needing to create and find resources with little to no help when it comes to attending a post-secondary institution. Now that I’m enrolled in UMBC and still struggling to find a DSP/PCA, I realize how desperate the need is for colleges and universities to offer direct support services for students with documented moderate to severe disabilities who need them to attend college.

 

As a Social Work major/Political Science minor, part of my mission is to advocate for changes in the law that would require DSPs / PCAs at the college level.  The proposed change would be an addition to RISE Act, which clarifies documentations used in context of higher education to show proof that a student has a disability. Right now, most colleges don’t offer these services and there are currently few resources that would help me find and hire such a person. For the past four years, it has been entirely up to myself and my parents to locate, interview and employ someone to attend college with me; an additional burden that my college peers are not subject to. The lack of support person, in my case and others like me, is a barrier to education and something that I believe needs to be changed.

 

The RISE Act should require that all schools review the documentation of a student’s need for specific accommodations and agree to assign a direct support professional to meet a student’s course schedule without being left alone on campus. Registered nurses and home health aides should be made available to those in need of constant medical supervision. If a student plans to live on campus and actively participate in programs of study and student organizations, it should be the college’s responsibility to ensure he/she not only has adequate access to direct care but also someone to provide personal safety for those who need it.

 

In public school, I was able to enjoy many extracurricular activities and network with my peers, especially with a fair amount of help needed from a DSP/PCA. I was happy with the benefit under IDEA that enabled me to receive mainstream education, even though my parents had to fight very hard on my behalf. Unfortunately, as a college student I have very limited availability of support to be on campus all day and it interferes with my ability to do anything social, which is a significant part of the college experience.

 

The policy changes I will be working toward will include the following:

Grant funding to university student disability service programs for employee training and recruitment.

Contracts signed by a student each semester to demonstrate that he/she agrees to receive DSP services.

 Assurance by the college that a student receives a certain number of hours of personal support during regular class schedule and for extracurricular activities.

 

I am confident that such changes would be life changing and improve the lives of students who have unique disabilities along with the capacity to manage direct care in continuing education and beyond. Equal access to education should not stop when a person graduates from high school.  We need to begin making post-secondary education a priority and go through the process of creating a system where students with disabilities should not have the additional burden of locating and hiring on-campus support to access their educational standards. Hiring a good support worker is an emotional roller coaster which I am aware of because I understand how frustrating it has been for me and my family when there is a shortage of resources for recruiting direct support professionals. The proposed policy changes would break down the barriers by improving access to higher education with more direct support provided at a university level. My greatest wish is to be a regular person like my able-bodied brother who is now a freshman at American University and a full-term student.  If I could receive reliable and guaranteed DSP/PCA support, I’d feel better about my educational experiences and less like an outsider.